He continued: "We've expressed this position previously clearly and consistently to successive US administrations and nothing is going to change that."Former Labour security minister
Lord West BBC Radio 4's The World Tonight programme the Pentagon leak on the Falklands was "quite extraordinary" and showed "a lack of understanding".
Lord West, who was an officer commanding HMS Ardent during the Falklands War, went on to describe US Defence Secretary
Pete Hegseth as "thick" and accused him of having a total lack of understanding about
NATO."Hegseth talks about the fact that
NATO's never done anything for America, America's done so much for
NATO, but the only time that Article 5 was invoked was by
NATO and it was to defend the
United States," he said."I'm afraid he's thick actually, and he doesn't seem to have a very good knowledge of a lot of these things, but to say that is stupid."Under
NATO's Article 5, an armed attack against one or more members is considered an attack against all, and in response each other member would take "such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force, to restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area".The only time Article 5 has been invoked was after the 9/11 attacks on the US in 2001.Previous US administrations have formally recognised the UK's de facto administration of the islands, but have not taken a formal position regarding sovereignty. While the White House is yet to comment on the report, it could prove to be another point of friction between the US and UK at a time of diplomatic tension.Trump has previously said he is "not happy" with the level of support offered by the UK during its war in Iran, while
Sir Keir Starmer has repeatedly said Britain will not be drawn into a wider conflict.Meanwhile, an official from
NATO - responding to the suggestion in the report that the US could push for
Spain's expulsion from the military alliance - said its founding treaty "does not foresee any provision for suspension of
NATO membership, or expulsion".Earlier,
Spain's Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez said: "We do not work based on emails. We work with official documents and official positions taken, in this case, by the government of the
United States."The
Falkland Islands have been under British rule since 1833, but
Argentina has historically said it has a right to them on the basis it inherited them from the Spanish crown, as well as the islands' proximity to the South American mainland.In 1982, a 10-week conflict between the UK and
Argentina over the islands was triggered when the latter's military dictator, Leopoldo Galtieri, ordered his country's forces to invade them.The then UK Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher's government sent a naval task force to recapture the islands.Argentine forces surrendered, but the country still claims sovereignty over the Falklands, which it calls the Malvinas and which lie about 300 miles (483km) east of
Argentina.In the course of the conflict, 649 Argentine military personnel and 255 British military personnel lost their lives, as well as three Falkland Islanders.More recently, Falkland Islanders have overwhelmingly expressed their desire to remain as a British territory. A 2013 referendum among the island's 1,672 eligible voters saw all but three voting to continue as an overseas territory, on a turnout of more than 90%.Successive British governments have long maintained that the island's population has a right to self-determination under international law established by the United Nations Charter.
Argentina's foreign minister Pablo Quirno wrote on X on Friday that his country rejected this, stating that those living in the
Falkland Islands had never been recognised as a people by the UN."
Argentina reaffirms its sovereign rights over the Malvinas Islands", Quirno wrote, adding: "The Argentine Republic once again expresses its willingness to resume bilateral negotiations with the
United Kingdom that will allow for finding a peaceful and definitive solution to the sovereignty dispute."Milei, who is a close ally of Trump, previously said it would take decades for the dispute to be resolved, and criticised Argentine politicians who "beat their chests demanding sovereignty of the islands, but without any result".