UK study to examine effects of restricting social media for children

A pioneering investigation into the impact of restricting social media access for children in the UK has been announced as politicians around the world consider action on the issue.In December, Australia became the first country to ban under-16s from social media, with governments in other countries – including the UK – under pressure to do the same.However, while experts say there is evidence that aspects of social media are harmful to most children, there has been no large-scale experimental study exploring the effect of limiting time spent on social media in healthy children as a population.“This study is a world first to try to look at that question,” said Prof Amy Orben, of the University of Cambridge, who is co-lead of the new study.Orben and colleagues plan to study about 4,000 children across 30 secondary schools in Bradford, West Yorkshire, focusing on students in years 8, 9 and 10.All participants will be asked to complete an initial questionnaire on areas including their mental health, sleep and friendships, and to download the research app on their main device.Each year group in each school will then be randomly assigned to one of two conditions: either the app will simply record students’ social media use, or the app will curtail students’ social media use by limiting their access to the apps for TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, X, LinkedIn, Reddit, YouTube and Snapchat to one hour a day, as well as imposing a curfew from 9pm to 7am.Crucially, the team say, all students within a particular year group in a school will experience the same intervention.“We know that if we take away social media for one adolescent, that might have a very different impact than if we take it away for their whole friendship group for a certain period of time,” said Orben.Access to messaging apps including WhatsApp will not be restricted, the team say, as they are important for family communication.After six weeks students will complete another questionnaire. After an initial pilot period beginning in April, the team plan to start the study itself in October, with the first results expected in summer 2027.While researchers note the study, called the IRL trial, has limitations – for example students may use devices that belong to other people or may choose not to participate – they hope the results will shed light on the effect of restricting teens’ social media use.“The participants’ levels of anxiety is our key outcome, and we’re also interested in depression,” said Dr Dan Lewer, who leads the Bradford Centre for Health Data Science and is co-lead of the study, adding the researchers would also explore the mechanisms of the impact by looking at which apps were used and when, as well as participants’ sleep patterns, experiences of bullying, time spent with friends and family, and how they compared themselves to other young people.The trial is independent from the UK government’s announcement of a consultation on whether to ban under-16s from social media, said Orben, adding that the results may be valuable for other countries debating the issue.“The decision that policymakers need to make is up to them,” she said. “We’re really just delivering the best quality evidence we can in the timeframes that are available.”