NEWSAR
Multi-perspective news intelligence

Susan Collins Dismissed Our Reporting as Old News. Some of Her Claims Aren’t True.

2 articles
2 sources
0% diversity
Updated 24.9.2026
Key Topics & People
Navatek *Susan Collins Martin Kao ProPublica Federal Bureau of Investigation

Coverage Framing

2
Political Strategy(2)
Avg Factuality:65%
Avg Sensationalism:High

Story Timeline

Sep 24 Morning

1 articles|1 sources
susan collinsnavatekcorruptioncampaign financefbi investigation
Political Strategy(1)
ProPublicaSep 24

Susan Collins Dismissed Our Reporting as Old News. Some of Her Claims Aren’t True.

ProPublica's investigation reveals that Senator Susan Collins and her aides have made inaccurate claims regarding an FBI inquiry into her relationship with Navatek CEO Martin Kao. Kao, who pleaded guilty to fraud, alleged he exchanged campaign cash for government contracts. While Collins stated the Biden Justice Department cleared her, the FBI investigation, based on Kao's claims from 2022-2024, was ongoing until early 2025 and was shut down under the Trump administration. FBI records indicate agents corroborated some of Kao's statements, despite his credibility issues. Collins' campaign has denied wrongdoing, but the article highlights discrepancies in their defense.

Mixed toneFactual3 sources
Negative

Key Claims

quote

Collins stated the Biden Justice Department cleared her office, campaign, and herself five years ago of allegations.

— Susan Collins

factual

Sen. Susan Collins and her aides made incorrect and misleading claims in their defense regarding her relationship with defense contractor Navatek.

— Article

factual

The FBI had been investigating Collins, her aides, and a pro-Collins super PAC regarding their relationship with Navatek.

— ProPublica investigation

factual

The investigation at the center of the ProPublica story was based on claims made between 2022-2024, not seven years ago.

— Article

factual

Martin Kao provided FBI agents with a 50-page document with new allegations about his interactions with elected officials, including Collins, in September 2024.

— Article citing FBI records

Sep 23 Evening

1 articles|1 sources
pay-to-playcorruptionsusan collinsbribery inquirypropublica report
Political Strategy(1)
The Guardian - World NewsSep 23

Democrats accuse Susan Collins of corruption after bombshell ‘pay-to-play’ report

Democrats in Maine are accusing Republican Senator Susan Collins of corruption following a ProPublica report detailing an alleged "pay-to-play" scheme. The report claims the head of Collins's Super PAC solicited a campaign donation from contracting firm Navatek, which then received assurances of federal contracts. According to ProPublica, the FBI had proposed investigating this arrangement for bribery, but the inquiry was reportedly derailed after Donald Trump returned to power. Collins's campaign has called the allegations "categorically false," stating the Justice Department and FBI under the Biden administration found no basis to charge her. The report has emerged as a significant issue in the race for Collins's Senate seat, which is considered a toss-up.

SensationalMixed3 sources
Negative

Key Claims

quote

Troy Jackson stated, 'This is corruption of the highest order.'

— Troy Jackson

factual

Democrats accuse Susan Collins of corruption following a ProPublica report about an alleged FBI bribery investigation.

— Democrats

factual

Collins' office called the ProPublica report 'categorically false' and noted Kao is in federal prison for fraud.

— Annie Clark (Collins' deputy chief of staff)

factual

ProPublica reported that the FBI proposed investigating Collins for accepting bribes before Trump allegedly derailed the inquiry.

— ProPublica

factual

Navatek CEO Martin Kao allegedly sent $150,000 to Collins' Super Pac, with assurances of government contracts in return.

— ProPublica