NEWSAR
Multi-perspective news intelligence

South Korea loses Canada submarine deal but cements top-tier defence status

7 articles
4 sources
0% diversity
Updated Yesterday
Key Topics & People
Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems *ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems Hanwha Ocean Mark Carney Canada

Coverage Framing

5
2
National Security(5)
Diplomatic(2)
Avg Factuality:79%
Avg Sensationalism:Low

Story Timeline

Jul 5 – Jul 11

6 articles|4 sources
thyssenkrupp marine systemscanadasubmarinesnatogermany
National Security(4)
The Guardian - World News2d ago

Canada to buy 12 hi-tech German submarines after bidding war

Canada has selected a German consortium, ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS), to build twelve new submarines. This multibillion-dollar contract, potentially exceeding $70 billion with maintenance, aims to replace Canada's aging fleet and deepen its NATO ties. TKMS beat out South Korean rival Hanwha Ocean in a competitive bidding process. The new submarines are expected to enhance Canada's presence in the Arctic through advanced stealth technology. This significant defense procurement aligns with Canada's commitment to increasing defense spending and diversifying its military suppliers. Final contract negotiations with TKMS are expected to take several years.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Positive
Associated Press (AP)2d ago

Canada selects Germany’s ThyssenKrupp to build 12 submarines as it boosts NATO spending

Canada has selected Germany's ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems as the preferred supplier to build 12 conventionally powered submarines. This significant military procurement, described as the largest in Canadian history, aims to replace the country's aging fleet and bolster its defense capabilities. The decision was announced by Prime Minister Mark Carney ahead of a NATO summit, where Canada is increasing its defense spending to meet alliance targets. ThyssenKrupp was chosen over South Korea's Hanwha Ocean, with the German company's submarines expected to enhance interoperability among NATO allies. Canada plans to have four new submarines by 2034 as part of its commitment to raise defense spending to 5% of GDP by 2035.

MeasuredFactual2 sources
Positive
Al Jazeera2d ago

Canada picks Germany’s TKMS for new submarines

Canada has selected Germany's TKMS, a naval shipbuilder majority-owned by Thyssenkrupp, to construct up to 12 new submarines. This significant defense procurement, the largest in Canada's history, aims to replace the nation's aging submarine fleet. TKMS partnered with NATO ally Norway for its bid, successfully outcompeting South Korea's Hanwha Ocean. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau stated the move will enhance Canada's strategic capabilities and autonomy. The contract is expected to be finalized by the end of next year, with the first submarines anticipated for delivery by 2034. This decision comes as Canada, like other NATO members, faces pressure to increase defense spending and has met NATO's 2% GDP target earlier than planned.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Positive
Diplomatic(2)
South China Morning PostYesterday

South Korea loses Canada submarine deal but cements top-tier defence status

Canada has selected Germany's Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) as the preferred bidder for its multibillion-dollar submarine project, worth approximately $40 billion. South Korea, which was also in contention, did not win the deal to build up to 12 diesel-electric submarines. Despite losing the contract, analysts suggest South Korea's strong performance in the close competition demonstrates its capability to compete with established global undersea warfare powers. This close contest is seen as a significant achievement for Seoul's defense industry, attracting attention from other potential defense buyers.

MeasuredFactual1 source
Positive
South China Morning Post2d ago

Canada picks German firm for new submarine fleet, South Korean competitor loses out

Canada has selected German defense contractor Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) to build its new multibillion-dollar submarine fleet, opting over South Korean competitor Hanwha Ocean Company. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announced the decision, stating it aligns with commitments to defend Canada and support allies. This move is anticipated to strengthen Canada's ties with NATO, especially as the alliance holds a summit in Ankara, Turkey. The article suggests this decision reflects a trend of mid-tier nations increasing collaboration due to perceived unreliability from the United States.

MeasuredFactual2 sources
Neutral

Key Claims

factual

South Korea lost Canada's multibillion-dollar submarine order to Germany.

— Article

quote

Canada selected Thyssenkrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) as the preferred bidder for its patrol submarine project.

— Prime Minister Mark Carney

factual

Canada has selected Germany's TKMS to build up to 12 submarines to replace its aging fleet.

factual

The deal is the largest defense procurement in Canada's history.

factual

Canada has now hit NATO's military spending target of 2 percent of GDP earlier than planned.

Apr 26 – May 2

1 articles|1 sources
aukus agreementnuclear submarinesuk inquiryuk shipbuildingaustralia security
National Security(1)
The Guardian - World NewsApr 28

‘Shortcomings and failures’ could sink Aukus nuclear submarines plan, UK inquiry warns

A UK parliamentary inquiry warns that "shortcomings and failures" in the UK's funding and commitment could jeopardize the Aukus nuclear submarine plan, impacting Australia's security. The report highlights decades of under-funding in UK shipbuilding and critically low submarine availability, evidenced by the HMS Anson's early recall. The inquiry found a decline in political leadership for the complex, long-term Aukus program, urging the Prime Minister to take a more visible role. Australia relies on the UK for designing and building a new class of nuclear submarines, the SSN-Aukus, and any UK delays or failures could leave Australia without a long-term submarine capability. The Aukus agreement's first pillar involves Australia acquiring US Virginia-class submarines and later, UK-designed Aukus submarines.

Mixed toneFactual2 sources
Negative

Key Claims

factual

When the HMS Anson visited Australia in February, it was Britain’s only attack-class submarine at sea.

factual

The US president must certify that selling Virginia-class submarines will not diminish US navy undersea capability before any sale to Australia.

statistic

The US submarine fleet currently has 49 boats, which is only three-quarters of its force-level goal of 66.

factual

UK shipbuilding has been under-funded for decades and the country’s submarine availability is 'critically low'.

— House of Commons defence committee

statistic

Aukus is forecast to cost Australia up to A$368bn through to the mid-2050s.

— Australia’s submarine industry strategy