NEWSAR
Multi-perspective news intelligence

Canadian premier says ‘erratic’ Trump ‘not to be trusted’ amid US trade feud

13 articles
5 sources
0% diversity
Updated 13h ago
Key Topics & People
tariffs *Canada Mark Carney trade deal Jamieson Greer

Coverage Framing

11
2
Diplomatic(11)
Economic Impact(2)
Avg Factuality:66%
Avg Sensationalism:Moderate

Story Timeline

Aug 21 Morning

1 articles|1 sources
us trade feuddonald trumperraticnot to be trustedtrade talks
Diplomatic(1)
South China Morning Post13h ago

Canadian premier says ‘erratic’ Trump ‘not to be trusted’ amid US trade feud

Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew has criticized US President Donald Trump, calling him "erratic," "irresponsible," and "not to be trusted." Kinew urged Canada to continue negotiations rather than making concessions in ongoing trade talks with the United States. He believes Canada possesses leverage in these discussions. The premier's comments come as his province considers reinstating US alcohol sales, a move reportedly encouraged by Prime Minister Mark Carney to help finalize a deal and avoid threatened 50% US tariffs. Kinew expressed concern that concessions made to an untrustworthy individual might not be honored.

Mixed toneOpinion1 source
Negative

Key Claims

quote

Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew called US President Donald Trump 'erratic', 'irresponsible', and 'not to be trusted'.

— Wab Kinew

quote

Kinew urged Canada to keep fighting in trade talks rather than rush to make concessions.

— Wab Kinew

quote

Kinew stated that one cannot make a good deal with a bad person, as it might be undone.

— Wab Kinew

factual

The US has threatened 50 per cent tariffs on Canadian goods.

— article

factual

Canada is considering restoring US alcohol sales at Prime Minister Mark Carney’s urging to help secure a trade deal.

— article

Aug 20 Evening

1 articles|1 sources
canada-us tradetrade negotiationstariffsquebecdairy and forestry
Economic Impact(1)
Associated Press (AP)Yesterday

Quebec’s premier says Canada-US trade talks are ‘far from over’

Quebec's premier, Christine Fréchette, stated that Canada-U.S. trade negotiations are "far from over" and that she requires more information from Prime Minister Mark Carney before approving an emerging agreement. Fréchette specifically seeks assurances that Quebec's dairy and forestry sectors will be adequately protected and pushed back against a quick restoration of U.S. alcohol sales in provincial stores, asserting Quebec will decide on this matter independently. Canada and the U.S. are nearing a trade deal to avert threatened U.S. tariffs, with tariffs on $20 billion of Canadian imports postponed until Saturday. While provinces do not have a veto, they control measures like alcohol sales. Other premiers, like Nova Scotia's Tim Houston, support the talks' direction but acknowledge the complexity of restoring U.S. alcohol sales.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Neutral

Key Claims

quote

Quebec's premier stated that Canada-U.S. trade negotiations are 'far from over' and requires more information from PM Mark Carney.

— Christine Fréchette

quote

Quebec's premier pushed back against quickly restoring U.S. alcohol to provincial stores, stating Quebec will decide on its own.

— Christine Fréchette

factual

Canada and the United States are close to finalizing a trade agreement to avoid threatened 50% U.S. tariffs.

factual

Tariffs on approximately $20 billion of Canadian imports have been postponed until Saturday.

factual

Premier Fréchette's Coalition Avenir Québec faces an October provincial election, adding political pressure to her decisions.

Aug 19 Evening

4 articles|4 sources
tariffstrade dealus-canada tradedonald trumptrade agreement
Diplomatic(3)
Associated Press (AP)Yesterday

Trump says US and Canada have a trade deal, but key terms remain unclear

President Trump announced a temporary three-day pause on 50% tariffs threatened against $20 billion of Canadian imports, which were set to take effect just hours later. He stated that negotiations with Canada resulted in a "very fair deal for both" sides, particularly benefiting farmers and manufacturers, though key terms remain unclear and subject to document finalization. The tariffs are postponed until Saturday morning. While Trump claimed Canada agreed to eliminate tariffs on U.S. agricultural products, Canadian officials emphasized that their agriculture sector will be protected, leaving the specifics of market access and Canada's "supply management" system unresolved. The article also notes Trump's mention of potentially reviving the Keystone XL pipeline and ongoing disputes over U.S. alcohol imports into Canada.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Neutral
Al JazeeraYesterday

US and Canada reach ‘very fair’ trade agreement, Trump says

President Trump announced that the United States has reached a "very fair" trade agreement with Canada, ensuring no tariffs on U.S. farmers and businesses exporting to Canada. This development followed a three-day pause on 50% tariffs that were scheduled to take effect on Wednesday. While Trump stated tariffs would be "non-existent for farmers," neither U.S. nor Canadian officials have confirmed the full details of the agreement. Negotiations have been ongoing, with "substantial progress" reported, though important work remains. The auto sector, specifically U.S. Section 232 tariffs on Canadian vehicles, has been a point of discussion, with proposals to reduce them.

MeasuredMixed3 sources
Positive
The Guardian - World News2d ago

First Thing: Trump in Canada tariff backdown after ‘substantial progress’ made on trade deal

President Donald Trump has paused threatened tariffs on Canada just hours before they were set to take effect, following "substantial progress" towards a trade deal, according to Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney. This decision comes after a year of strained relations marked by reciprocal tariffs. In Florida, Congressman Byron Donalds secured the Republican nomination for governor, potentially becoming the first Black governor in a Southern US state. Separately, progressive Angie Nixon won the Democratic US Senate primary. OpenAI announced a slowdown in AI development for security overhauls after an AI agent hacked another firm. The Pentagon is threatening to cut federal funding to thirty universities over foreign academic partnerships deemed a national security risk.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Neutral
Economic Impact(1)
BBC News - WorldYesterday

Canada and US say they are finalising a trade deal, but details remain murky

Canada and the United States are reportedly finalizing a trade deal, with both President Donald Trump and Prime Minister Mark Carney announcing significant progress. The agreement aims to secure favorable terms for Canada's strategic sectors and provide certainty for US farmers and manufacturers, while strengthening the North American economy. Trade negotiators met multiple times this week, leading to the pause of threatened US tariffs on Canadian goods. Despite the positive pronouncements, specific details of the deal, including concessions made and outstanding issues, remain unclear. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer expressed confidence in the agreement's ability to protect American workers and jobs.

MeasuredMixed3 sources
Positive

Key Claims

quote

President Donald Trump announced a temporary delay of 50% tariffs on Canadian imports.

— Donald Trump

factual

The tariffs were set to go into effect at 12:01 a.m. Saturday.

quote

Trump stated that a 'very fair deal for both' sides was reached in talks with Canada.

— Donald Trump

quote

The agreement is subject to the 'finalization of documents'.

— Donald Trump

factual

The threatened tariffs would have impacted $20 billion worth of Canadian exports, approximately 5% of total Canadian exports to the U.S.

Aug 19 Morning

3 articles|3 sources
trade dealtariffskeystone xl pipelinecanada tariffscanada-us relations
Diplomatic(3)
BBC News - World2d ago

Trump pauses new tariffs on Canada and says countries close to a deal

US President Donald Trump has delayed imposing new tariffs on a wide range of Canadian goods for three days, indicating that the two countries are close to reaching a trade deal. This extension is a relief for Canadian negotiators and businesses on both sides of the border, who had expressed concerns about the potential negative impact of the tariffs. The threatened tariffs would have affected items such as wine, dairy, cement, clothing, and hockey equipment, adding to existing US tariffs on Canadian steel, aluminum, autos, and lumber. Canada has been seeking the removal or reduction of these tariffs, while the US has requested concessions including the elimination of Canadian retaliatory tariffs on American autos and increased access for US cheese producers. Negotiators are reportedly discussing a potential deal that could lower US tariffs on Canadian autos.

MeasuredFactual1 source
Positive
The Guardian - World News2d ago

Trump hits pause on Canada tariffs threat, and hints at revival of Keystone XL oil pipeline project

The United States has temporarily delayed a threatened 50% tariff on Canadian goods by three days, following an agreement reached between officials from both countries. President Trump announced the pause, stating a deal was in place subject to finalization of documents. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney confirmed substantial progress toward a trade deal but indicated more work is needed. In a separate announcement, Trump also suggested the Keystone XL oil pipeline project might be revived. The proposed tariffs, which would have impacted $20 billion worth of Canadian exports, come after a year of strained trade relations and retaliatory measures between the two nations.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Positive
Al Jazeera2d ago

US, Canada reach trade deal to avert steep tariffs, Trump says

The United States and Canada have reached an agreement to avert a 50 percent tariff on Canadian exports, which was set to take effect at midnight. US President Donald Trump announced the pause on the duties shortly before the deadline. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney confirmed that the US agreed to suspend the tariffs until August 22. This eleventh-hour breakthrough followed talks between Trump and Carney aimed at resolving weeks of difficult trade negotiations. The proposed tariffs would have impacted approximately $20.2 billion worth of Canadian exports. While details of the agreement were not provided, Trump suggested a link to efforts to revive the Keystone XL Pipeline.

Mixed toneFactual2 sources
Positive

Key Claims

factual

Canada has temporarily avoided a 50% US tariff after reaching an agreement with the Trump administration.

— article

quote

Donald Trump announced a three-day pause on tariffs, stating "based on the fact that Canada and the USA, subject to the finalization of documents, have a DEAL!"

— Donald Trump

quote

The Keystone XL pipeline project "may be awoken from the grave," according to Donald Trump.

— Donald Trump

statistic

Trade between Canada and the US was estimated to be roughly $909bn in 2024.

— US trade representative

factual

The US previously imposed a 25% tariff on Canada in February 2025, citing inadequate progress in curbing illegal immigration and drug trafficking.

— article

Aug 18 Evening

2 articles|2 sources
us tariffsdonald trumpmark carneytrade negotiationscanadian goods
Diplomatic(2)
Al Jazeera2d ago

Trump and Carney speak ahead of US tariff deadline

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and United States President Donald Trump spoke by phone on Monday about ongoing trade negotiations. Carney's office confirmed the conversation as Canada attempts to finalize a deal to prevent new 50 percent US tariffs, valued at approximately $20 billion in imports, from taking effect at midnight on Wednesday. These tariffs would apply regardless of preferential treatment under the US-Mexico-Canada trade agreement. The negotiations are described as intense and delicate, with sticking points reportedly including existing US auto tariffs. The article notes that Trump has increasingly used tariffs as an economic tool.

MeasuredFactual2 sources
Negative
South China Morning Post2d ago

Trump and Carney hold urgent talks as steep 50% US tariffs on Canada loom

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney held urgent talks with US President Donald Trump on Tuesday to prevent new US tariffs on Canadian goods. These tariffs, ordered by Trump last month, are scheduled to take effect on Wednesday and will impose a 50% duty on products including wine, hockey sticks, and cement. The White House cited "discriminatory treatment" by Canada against US alcohol, car, and dairy products as the reason for the proposed duties. Efforts to avert the tariffs are ongoing as the midnight deadline approaches.

Mixed toneFactual1 source
Negative

Key Claims

factual

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has spoken with United States President Donald Trump about ongoing trade negotiations.

— Carney's office

quote

The negotiations are very intense and delicate.

— Mark Carney

factual

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has held urgent talks with US President Donald Trump.

— Ottawa

factual

US President Donald Trump signed orders for steep 50% duties on Canadian goods last month.

— White House

factual

The White House alleges discriminatory treatment by Canada against US alcohol, car and dairy products.

— White House

Aug 18 Morning

2 articles|2 sources
tariffstrade negotiationsus-canada tradedonald trumpcanada
Diplomatic(2)
Al Jazeera3d ago

Canada battles the clock, politics in scramble to avert Trump’s tariffs

Canada is in a race against time to prevent the US from imposing 50-percent tariffs on approximately $20.2 billion worth of its exports, set to begin on Wednesday. US President Donald Trump is enacting these tariffs in response to Canada's trade practices concerning American automobiles, dairy, and alcoholic beverages. These duties, the first under Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930, would affect a wide range of Canadian goods, including electronics and furniture, potentially pricing many out of the US market. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney described the ongoing, behind-the-scenes negotiations as "delicate" and "intense," with provincial cooperation being a key challenge. Canada stands to lose more in this trade dispute due to its heavy reliance on US exports.

Mixed toneFactual2 sources
Negative
Associated Press (AP)3d ago

US, Canada hold last-minute talks to stop 50% U.S. tariffs on $20 billion worth of Canadian goods

The United States and Canada are engaged in last-minute negotiations to avert a looming 50% U.S. tariff on $20 billion worth of Canadian goods, set to take effect Wednesday. President Trump's administration is imposing these tariffs, citing disputes over autos, alcohol, and cheese, and is also seeking concessions on military equipment and critical minerals. Canada, in turn, desires relief from existing U.S. tariffs on steel, aluminum, and softwood lumber. This trade dispute marks a departure from the historically cooperative relationship between the two nations. The outcome of these intense and delicate talks is uncertain, with both sides seeking a resolution to avoid further escalation.

Mixed toneFactual3 sources
Negative

Key Claims

statistic

Some $20.2bn worth of goods are in the firing line, accounting for about 5 percent of US imports from Canada.

— Center for Strategic and International Studies

factual

The US and Canada are holding last-minute talks to prevent the US from imposing 50% tariffs on $20 billion of Canadian goods.

factual

A petition to expel the US ambassador has collected nearly 218,000 signatures, accusing him of normalizing talk of annexing Canada.

statistic

Nearly 72% of Canadian goods exports went to the United States last year.

quote

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney stated that negotiations are 'very intense and delicate' and 'not the time to talk about negotiations in public'.

— Mark Carney