NEWSAR
Multi-perspective news intelligence

United Nations votes 164-1 for Equal Earth map after US brands it 'radical ideological project'

9 articles
6 sources
0% diversity
Updated 15h ago
Key Topics & People
United Nations General Assembly *Africa Mercator map Togo Gerardus Mercator

Coverage Framing

5
3
1
Diplomatic(5)
Social Justice(3)
Economic Impact(1)
Avg Factuality:80%
Avg Sensationalism:Low

Story Timeline

Sep 5 Evening

3 articles|3 sources
mercator projectionafrica's true sizeequal earth mapun map resolutionworld maps
Diplomatic(2)
Fox News - World15h ago

United Nations votes 164-1 for Equal Earth map after US brands it 'radical ideological project'

The United Nations General Assembly voted 164-1 to adopt the Equal Earth map projection, which depicts continents in their true relative sizes, notably showing Africa as significantly larger than on traditional maps like the Mercator projection. The United States was the sole nation to vote against the resolution, with its deputy representative calling it a "radical ideological project" rather than a simple cartographic update. Togo's Foreign Minister introduced the resolution on behalf of the African Group, stating that the new map would promote a more just perspective and understanding among nations. While the resolution doesn't mandate abandoning the Mercator projection, it signifies the UN's official endorsement of equal-area maps. Six nations abstained from the vote.

MeasuredFactual3 sources
Neutral
Al Jazeera20h ago

How big is Africa really? Why the UN voted to change the world map

The United Nations General Assembly has voted to back a resolution, spearheaded by African countries, to adopt a new world map projection called Equal Earth. This new map, supported by 164 countries, aims to provide a more accurate representation of continental landmasses, showing Africa, Latin America, South Asia, and Oceania as significantly larger than they appear on the traditional Mercator projection. The Mercator projection, created in 1569 for maritime navigation, distorts the relative sizes of landmasses, making northern regions appear larger and equatorial regions smaller. Togo drove the resolution, emphasizing that maps influence perceptions and education. The United States voted against the resolution, arguing it distracts from more pressing issues, while six other countries abstained. The UN is encouraging member states to adopt the Equal Earth projection, though the resolution is not binding.

MeasuredFactual2 sources
Positive
Economic Impact(1)
BBC News - World19h ago

What different world maps get right - and what they get wrong

The article discusses the inaccuracies of world maps, particularly the widely used Mercator projection. Created over 450 years ago, the Mercator map accurately represents compass bearings as straight lines but distorts the size of landmasses. This projection makes countries near the equator appear smaller and those near the poles larger, a consequence of flattening a spherical Earth onto a two-dimensional surface. Critics argue this distortion can psychologically influence perceptions of importance, implicitly downplaying regions like Africa. The UN's adoption of a new map reflecting Africa's true size highlights the ongoing debate about how maps shape political and economic perceptions.

MeasuredFactual2 sources
Neutral

Key Claims

statistic

The United Nations voted 164-1 to adopt the Equal Earth map projection.

— United Nations

factual

The United States was the only nation to vote against adopting the Equal Earth map.

— United Nations

factual

The Equal Earth map depicts countries and continents in their true relative sizes.

— map creator's website

quote

The US representative called the resolution a 'radical ideological project'.

— Yaryna Ferencevych

factual

The Mercator projection, created in 1569, enlarges land masses near the poles and reduces those near the equator.

— article

Sep 5 Morning

2 articles|2 sources
africa's sizeun general assemblycartographyworld mapequal earth projection
Diplomatic(1)
Al JazeeraYesterday

UN approves new map showing Africa’s true size

The UN General Assembly has approved a resolution to update maps. This change aims to depict Africa's true size more accurately. The resolution was backed by the UN General Assembly, indicating a formal decision by this body. The purpose of this action is to correct the common misrepresentation of Africa's vast geographical scale on existing maps. This decision by the UN General Assembly will lead to the adoption of new cartographic representations that better reflect the continent's actual dimensions.

MeasuredFactual
Neutral
Social Justice(1)
Associated Press (AP)Yesterday

UN General Assembly endorses a new world map that shows more accurately Africa’s size

The United Nations General Assembly has endorsed a new world map that more accurately represents the size of Africa. The resolution, sponsored by Togo and supported by the African Union, passed with 164 member states in favor, with the U.S. voting against it. This endorsement encourages the global adoption of the Equal Earth projection over the traditional Mercator map, which significantly distorts the relative sizes of landmasses. While the Mercator map shows Greenland and Africa as similar in size, the Equal Earth projection illustrates Africa as 14 times larger than Greenland. The UN resolution encourages, but does not mandate, the use of the Equal Earth projection, aiming to improve global understanding and perceptions of the world.

MeasuredFactual5 sources
Positive

Key Claims

factual

The UN General Assembly has backed a resolution to change maps.

factual

The resolution aims to show the true size of Africa more accurately.

factual

The UN General Assembly endorsed a new world map that represents Africa more accurately in its larger size.

factual

The Equal Earth projection shows Africa is 14 times larger than Greenland, unlike the Mercator projection.

factual

The resolution encourages governments and institutions to replace the traditional Mercator map with the Equal Earth projection.

Sep 4 Evening

3 articles|3 sources
world mapafrica sizemercator mapun general assemblycartography
Diplomatic(2)
South China Morning PostYesterday

UN adopts new map: Africa bigger, North America and Europe smaller

The United Nations General Assembly has adopted a resolution, spearheaded by African countries, to use a new map projection known as the Equal Earth. This new map aims for a more accurate representation of continental landmasses, resulting in Africa appearing larger while North America and Europe are depicted as smaller. The resolution was supported by 164 member states, with the United States voting against it and six other countries abstaining. The UN General Assembly's decision on Friday signifies a move towards a cartographic representation considered more accurate by its proponents.

MeasuredFactual
Neutral
BBC News - WorldYesterday

UN votes to adopt new world map to reflect Africa's true size

The UN General Assembly has voted to adopt a new world map that more accurately depicts Africa's size. This resolution, sponsored by Togo and supported by African Union members, passed with 164 nations voting in favor, while the United States was the sole nation to vote against it, with six abstentions. The change addresses criticisms of the traditional Mercator map, which has been in use since the 16th century and inaccurately portrays Africa as being similar in size to Greenland, despite being 14 times larger. Critics argue this distortion can minimize the development needs and potential of equatorial countries. The Mercator map's distortions are a result of the inherent challenge in representing a globe on a flat surface.

MeasuredFactual
Positive
Social Justice(1)
Al JazeeraYesterday

UN votes to adopt new world map that reflects Africa’s true size

The United Nations General Assembly has voted to adopt a new world map projection, the Equal Earth, which more accurately represents the true size of countries, particularly Africa. This resolution, sponsored by African Union member states and the Bahamas, aims to correct historical distortions caused by the widely-used Mercator map, which has visually shrunk Africa for centuries. The Mercator map, developed in the 16th century, exaggerates landmasses closer to the poles, making Greenland appear similar in size to Africa, despite Africa being significantly larger. While not legally binding, the resolution encourages the use of more accurate maps in education, media, and digital platforms. The United States was the sole country to vote against the resolution, citing an "ideological agenda." France announced its intention to abandon the Mercator map in favor of more accurate representations.

MeasuredFactual4 sources
Positive

Key Claims

factual

The UN General Assembly adopted a resolution to adopt a new world map that more accurately reflects countries' true sizes.

— United Nations

factual

The Mercator map, developed in the 16th century, distorts relative landmass sizes by expanding those nearer the poles, making Greenland appear similar in size to Africa.

— Gerardus Mercator

statistic

Africa is approximately 14 times larger than Greenland.

statistic

The resolution was backed by a vote of 164-1 with six abstentions.

— United Nations

quote

The United States was the only country to vote against the resolution, stating it promoted an 'ideological agenda'.

— United States

Sep 4 Morning

1 articles|1 sources
mercator mapafrica's sizeun resolutioncartographic colonialismworld map accuracy
Social Justice(1)
The Guardian - World News2d ago

UN to vote on adopting new world map that shows Africa’s true scale

The UN General Assembly will vote on a resolution, sponsored by Togo and supported by African Union member states, to phase out the traditional Mercator map in favor of one that more accurately represents Africa's size. The 1569 Mercator projection distorts the relative sizes of landmasses, making equatorial regions appear smaller and high-latitude regions larger, leading to Africa being depicted as similar in size to Greenland when it is significantly larger. Proponents argue this is a scientific issue rooted in western stereotypes, and adopting an equal-area map like the 2018 Equal Earth design could reverse perceptions and decolonize global curricula. While UN resolutions are non-enforceable, a successful vote could influence educational materials and everyday technology.

MeasuredFactual4 sources
Positive

Key Claims

factual

The UN General Assembly will vote on a resolution to formally phase out the traditional Mercator map in favor of one that more accurately displays Africa's size.

— UN General Assembly

factual

The Mercator map, created in 1569, has remained the global standard but distorts the size of regions, making equatorial areas appear smaller and high-latitude areas larger.

— article

statistic

Africa is 14 times larger than Greenland, though the Mercator map shows them as similar in size.

— article

quote

Historians and geographers have stated the Mercator projection is rooted in western stereotypes, with some calling it 'cartographic colonialism'.

— Historians and geographers

factual

The #CorrectTheMap campaign promotes the 2018 Equal Earth Map, which supporters believe will help reverse perceptions of Africa and decolonize global curriculums.

— Supporters of the #CorrectTheMap campaign